Sir Edward Downes
born on 17/6/1924 in Birmingham, West Midlands, United Kingdom
died on 10/7/2009 in Zürich, ZH, Switzerland
Sir Edward Thomas ("Ted") Downes, CBE (17 June 1924 – 10 July 2009) was an English conductor, specialising in opera.
He was associated with the Royal Opera House from 1952, and with Opera Australia from 1970. He was also well known for his long working relationship with the BBC Philharmonic and for working with the Netherlands Radio Orchestra. Within the field of opera, he was particularly known as a conductor of Verdi.
He and his wife, Lady (Joan) Downes, committed assisted suicide at the Dignitas clinic in Switzerland on 10 July 2009, an event that received significant media coverage.
Early life and education
Downes was born in Birmingham, England in 1924, the son of a bank teller. He began to learn the piano and violin at age five and was also a choirboy, learning the organ and becoming choir master when his voice broke at 13. He left school at the age of 14 to earn his living in the City of Birmingham Gas Department, for 16s 10d (currently equal to 84p) a week.
Having spent his lunch hours studying by himself in Birmingham Central Library, he won a scholarship at the age of 16 to the University of Birmingham. Because his parents believed that a musical career was immoral, they made him leave home and he spent his university time as a fire watcher, living in the fire station, while he studied English literature and music. He began playing the horn. A scholarship to the Royal College of Music to study horn (with Frank Probin) and composition followed. Only weeks after starting the course, Probin sent Downes as his deputy on a tour with the London Symphony Orchestra, which continued over the years Downes spent at the College, but on leaving the Royal College he decided that orchestral playing would not be his career.
After some time on the staff at the University of Aberdeen, Downes' pursuit of conducting was aided by a two-year Carnegie scholarship which allowed him to study with Hermann Scherchen in Zurich.
In 1955 he married Joan Weston, a dancer with the Royal Ballet. She later became a choreographer and television producer. They had two children, a son, Caractacus (born December 1967), a musician and recording engineer, and a daughter, Boudicca (born 1970), a video producer.
After nearly two years with Scherchen, Downes returned to England and joined the Carl Rosa Opera Company as a répétiteur. After the company's temporary closure in 1951, Downes began a long and fruitful association with the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden in 1952 with his appointment as an assistant to Rafael Kubelík. His first job was prompting Maria Callas in her house debut. His first conducting assignment was taking over from John Barbirolli in La boheme in Bulawayo. At Covent Garden, it was in 1954 for Der Freischütz and he opened the next season with a new production of The Tales of Hoffmann. For the first production of the original Boris Godunov at Covent Garden with Boris Christoff, Kubelik persuaded Downes to learn Russian order to coach the English-speaking members of the cast; this was useful also when he conducted Dmitri Shostakovich's Katerina Ismailova in 1963, with the composer present at rehearsals.
Downes remained a company member for 17 years, returning annually thereafter as a guest conductor before assuming the post of Associate Music Director in 1991. Downes conducted at least 950 performances of 49 operas at Covent Garden.
Elsewhere, he became the Australian Opera's Music Director in 1970, conducting the first performance in the Sydney Opera House in 1973,  the Australian premiere of War and Peace by Sergei Prokofiev. He was Chief Conductor of the Netherlands Radio Orchestra until 1983. While Downes worked with many of the world's symphony orchestras, he enjoyed a particularly long relationship with the BBC Philharmonic (formerly the BBC Northern Symphony Orchestra), serving as its Chief Guest Conductor, then Principal Conductor, and finally as Conductor Emeritus.
Downes was noted for his championing of British music, and especially for Prokofiev and Verdi. He advocated the symphonies of George Lloyd (also conducting a radio performance of John Socman) and premiered works by Peter Maxwell Davies and Malcolm Arnold. His passion for Prokofiev was felt in performances of both major and lesser-known Prokofiev scores throughout the world. He also conducted the UK première of War and Peace at a concert performance at Leeds Town Hall in 1967. In 1979 he completed the orchestration of a one-act Prokofiev opera, Maddalena; he conducted its first recording in 1979 and its world premiere staging in 1981.
Downes' first experience of conducting the music of Verdi came when Rafael Kubelík withdrew from a Covent Garden Otello and Downes led the opera with no rehearsal. He felt on home ground, and then championed Verdi revivals in England. He conducted 25 of Verdi's 28 operas, and devised the idea to perform all of them in time for the 2001 centenary of the composer's death.
Downes once expressed regret that he had never conducted Alzira, Un Giorno di Regno nor, especially, Les vêpres siciliennes. The conductor said: "I seemed to understand Verdi as a person. He was a peasant. He had one foot in heaven and one on the earth. And this is why he appeals to all classes of people, from those who know everything about music to those who are hearing it for the first time."
At the BBC Proms he shared the platform with Pierre Boulez for the Proms premiere of Karlheinz Stockhausen's Gruppen in 1967, and conducted the Proms premieres of Die Jakobsleiter in 1968, Boris Godunov in 1971 and The Fiery Angel in 1991, as well as public premieres of George Lloyd's Symphony No. 6 and works by Smalley, Maconchy and Elias.
Downes was appointed Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE) in the 1986 New Year Honours, and was knighted in the 1991 Queen's Birthday Honours.
Although not terminally ill, Downes had been coping with increasing deafness and near total blindness for many years. He had become almost totally dependent on his wife after his health declined following a hip replacement. Lady Downes was diagnosed with terminal pancreatic cancer metastasised to her liver and given weeks to live.
Lady Downes wrote a letter to family explaining that she had decided against treatment and that:
- "All the plans that need to be made had been.
- Now, I must tell you that even though I had hoped to be around a bit longer, death doesnt worry me at all.
- I have no religion and, as far as I am concerned, it will be an "offswitch" so after you have thought about it a bit dont worry.
- It has been a happy and interesting life and I have no regrets. I have no idea how long I will last but I send love to you all and your extensive families.
- Enjoy it while it lasts.
- With love to you all, Joan."
Sir Edward, aged 85, and Lady Downes, aged 74, ended their lives by assisted suicide at the Dignitas clinic in Zürich, Switzerland, on 10 July 2009. Although Joan did not want the children present, Dignitas encouraged it and "Ted and Joanie" were reported to be pleased when the time came. Their children issued a statement speaking of "serious health problems" suffered by the couple. A statement issued by the couple's children said that while Downes could have gone on living with his deafness and blindness, he did not want to do so after his wife was diagnosed with terminal cancer.
In March 2010, Keir Starmer (director of public prosecutions) stated that Caractacus Downes would not be prosecuted for his involvement with his parents' assisted suicide because it was not in the public interest.
- 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 "Interview with Roy Plomley on Desert Island Discs, BBC radio, 1969 accessed 25 November 2013.
- 2.0 2.1 Alan Blyth and David Nice,"ObituarySir Edward DownesLeading conductor of Verdi at Covent Garden and a stalwart champion of Prokofiev"], The Guardian (London), 14 July 2009. Retrieved on 15 July 2009
- 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 Jill Lawless, "Conductor Downes, wife die in Swiss suicide clinic" Associated Press 14 July 2009)
- Sir Edward Downes at the Royal Opera House, partial search, accessed 25 November 2013.
- Keith Potter, "Opera and Concert Reports" (Proms). The Musical Times, 130(1760), pp. 621-35 (October 1989)
- Martin Kettle, "Interview: conductor Edward Downes", The Guardian, 14 June 2004
- London Gazette: (Supplement) no. 50361, page 7, 30 December 1985, Retrieved on 14 July 2009.
- London Gazette: (Supplement) no. 52563, page 2, 14 June 1991, Retrieved on 14 July 2009.
- 9.0 9.1 Appel, Jacob M., "Assisted Suicide for Healthy People?" July 16, 2009
- " 'They held hands as they lay down and waited for death': Son tells how he watched his parents die at Swiss suicide clinic" Daily Mail (London), 15 July 2009
- BBC "Conductor dies in suicide centre" 14 July 2009
- "Conductor Sir Edward Downes and wife end lives at Dignitas clinic", The Daily Telegraph (London), 14 July 2009
- "No assisted suicide charge for son of Sir Edward Downes", on BBC.co.uk. 19 March 2010
- Obituary: "Sir Edward Downes", The Daily Telegraph (London), 15 July 2009
- "Conductor dies in aided suicide", BBC.co.uk, July 14, 2009. Retrieved 4 May 2012
- Alan, Blyth, "Sir Edward Downes: Leading conductor of Verdi at Covent Garden and a stalwart champion of Prokofiev", The Guardian (London), 14 July 2009
- Charlotte Higgins and Owen Bowcott, "Sir Edward Downes and Lady Downes arrange natural finale", The Guardian (London), 14 July 2009
- Editorial: "In praise of ... Edward Downes", The Guardian (London), 15 July 2009
- I watched as my parents faced their dignified, peaceful death - together, Boudicca Downes, The Observer (London), 19 July 2009
- Edward Downes at the Internet Movie Database